What a check gives back
A brand check gives back one of four things. They are a score, a status for the asset, a verdict for each rule, and comments on the file. The most useful result also gives a reason, because a person or an agent needs the reason to fix the work.
What kinds of result are there?
- A score. Marq Brand Guardian scores a project against the brand standards. Adobe GenStudio gives a percentage of the brand guidelines that passed.
- A status for the asset. Bynder proposes Compliant, Non Compliant, Partially Compliant, or Not Applicable. Cloudinary gives Approved, Rejected, or Needs review.
- A verdict for each check, with a reason. Rainbrand returns pass, fail, uncertain, or not applicable for each check, with a short reason. Lytho gives Fail, Flagged, or Pass, with a comment.
- Comments on the file. IntelligenceBank marks each risk on the content as a markup comment. In a proofing tool, the reviewers write the comments.
Some products add a suggested fix. Markup AI suggests a correction for most issues, and Lytho gives a Suggested Fix with each comment.
What does an uncertain result mean?
Some products say when they are not sure. Lytho calls this state Flagged, Cloudinary calls it Needs review, and Rainbrand calls it uncertain. An uncertain result is not a pass. Count it as work for a person when you plan the review time.
What can an agent do with the result?
An agent can revise the work only if the result says what is wrong and where. A score alone does not tell the agent what to change. A verdict for each check with a reason does, and a suggested fix makes the next step shorter.
What does each product give back?
| Product | What the check gives back | Who decides |
|---|---|---|
| Adobe | Pass rate and results for each page | Suggests, then a person checks |
| Artwork Flow | Color-coded results and suggestions | Marks errors for reviewers |
| Bynder | Status and a rule-by-rule report | Proposes, a person approves |
| Cloudinary | Result, confidence, and explanation | People make the final call |
| Frontify | Answer with references | Advises in chat |
| IntelligenceBank | Comments on the file | Advises, a person decides |
| Lytho | Fail, Flagged, or Pass with comments | Advises people |
| Markup AI | Issues, reasons, fixes, scores | Advises |
| Rainbrand | A verdict, a reason, and evidence for each check | Your team. A Review returns findings, not an approval. |
| Writer | Score and suggested fixes | Advises |
| Filestage | Comments on the file | People decide |
| PageProof | Suggested markup and comments | People decide |
| Ziflow | Pass or fail for each item | People decide |
| Marq | Brand Guardian gives callouts that highlight possible issues on the project. Each callout gives a reason. | Brand Guardian advises. Users choose whether to make the changes that it suggests. |
| Templafy | Check for PowerPoint lists warnings by slide or by type in a task pane. A Fix button corrects one warning, and Fix All corrects several warnings. | Templafy says that it prevents brand issues when a document is created. It says that most other tools flag issues afterward. |
| PerformLine | The scanner gives each asset a compliance score from 0 to 100 with a Pass, Warning, or Fail verdict. | The Pre-Publication Scanner gives a verdict, and human reviewers make the final decision. |
| Siteimprove | For a brand voice issue, Brand Consistency gives a short reason and a recommendation to update the paragraph. | Brand Consistency reports issues, and people decide. A user marks each issue occurrence as Open, Acknowledged, or Dismissed. |